The death of Protestantism?

Last month the Pew Forum on Religion & Public Life released the results of an extensive new survey exploring the practices Americans use to demonstrate their religious affiliation.

Major Religious Traditions in the U.S.

The study details new statistics on religion in America and exposes  the shifts taking place in the U.S. religious landscape.

One of the findings was this; mainline Protestantism is declining.

This means the numbers of Lutherans, Presbyterians, Methodists and Baptists are shrinking.

The White Anglo Saxon Protestant (WASP) era is coming to a close.

Taking its place in the intellectual/cultural landscape is a rising population of Evangelical churches.  These folks have a far different vision for America than we enjoyed from Protestantism.

A few of the differences:

  • Governance: Mainline Protestants are governed by Bishops, Presbyters, Regional Ministers and Supervisors.  Evangelical churches, while “in communion” with each other,  are independent in theology and practice.
  • Professional Scrutiny: Mainline clergy (Lutheran, Presbyterian, Methodist etc.) are regularly held accountable for their theology and practice.  Evangelical leaders, due to the absence of governance, practice under the scrutiny of their congregational leaders and members.
  • Standards: Since they enjoy  no denominational scrutiny, Evangelical churches are not governed by standards, best practices or monitoring, as are mainline Protestant churches.
  • Theology: Protestants are trinitarians – seeing God in three articles of faith – the Creator, Redeemer and Sustainer.  Evangelicals focus upon Jesus and theological interpretations of the sacrifice of the Christ.
  • MORE Theology: Protestant theology provides room for mystery, questioning of authority and the practice of conscience. Evangelicals seek answers to the hard, religious questions of our times and require adherence to agreed-upon principles.
  • The End Times: Evangelicals believe salvation comes through submission to the authority of Jesus Christ. Without submission the believer is damned. They believe the end of the age is near and the reign of Christ is imminent. Protestants vary in their approach to eschatology, and stress living each day aligned with the principles of the faith.
  • Women, Gays, Lesbians, Single Folks and Sexuality: Evangelicals believe in the sanity of heterosexual marriage, the importance of traditional family values and the central ideals inherent in male-led households. Protestants ordain women, minister to single families, Some denominations allow the celebration of civil wedding ceremonies for gays and lesbians.
  • Separation of Church and State: Evangelicals seek inroads to government influence and welcome state sanction for their practices. They are the instigators of the faith-based initiatives funded first by the Bush administration and now by the Obama administration.  Protestants adhere to the separation principles of the United States Constitution.  Fiercely independent, mainline Protestant churches have a history of shielding their theologies and practices from government interference and support.

So, do you care about this?

You should.  Sociologist and cultural historian Max Weber identified Protestantism as a critical to our national personality in his 1905 text, The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism.  Weber’s analysis connected the dots between the Protestant theology emphasis on hard work, the steady rise of capital and the growth of our nation.

In essence, WASPS created the American dream, pushed capitalism to its limits, and created the society we currently enjoy.

Love them or hate them, the WASPS have changed the world.

So – what now?

Will the Evangelical influence continue on the same path?  Will Evangelicals create an American committed to compassion, freedom, forgiveness and generosity? How will the next stage of capitalism be influenced by the Evangelical theologies?  And will a nation, dominated by Evangelical belief systems make us a better people?

What do you think?

You Might Also Like

4 Replies to “The death of Protestantism?”

  1. Are not some Evangelical churches capitalist if they preach prosperity.

    The way Jesus lived in a travelling commune I think showed he was not a capitalist, but that he was a socialist.

    “Evangelicals focus upon Jesus”. The ones I know pray to God through Jesus and can feel the power of the Holy Spirit, and believe in three persons in one God.

    “Evangelical churches… are independent in theology”. They say they follow the Bible.

    Evangelicals have women pastors.

    “The White Anglo Saxon Protestant (WASP) era is coming to a close… So, do you care about this?… You should”. When put like that it doesn’t look very inclusive to me. Jesus accepted everyone not just his Jewish friends.

    But I don’t know that much about the USA really. Been there in 1985, 1989 and 1997. Nice place, but…

  2. “I think showed he was not a capitalist, but that he was a socialist.”

    I think the most scriptural idea is that each person should work to support himself and his family, but those who can not should be supported. Also, being in ministry IS work, as JEsus was supported by His followers, and the apostles were supported, and the ox is worth his food, etc.

    ““Evangelicals focus upon Jesus”. The ones I know pray to God through Jesus and can feel the power of the Holy Spirit, and believe in three persons in one God.”

    I would agree with you. But various groups of Christians tend to focus more on one person in the trinity than others. Charismatics tend to focus on the Holy Spirit. Catholics and the bunch of denominations that are direct close decendants of it tend to focus more on the Father. Non-Charismatic Evangelicals tend to focus on the Son. All three groups are aware of all three persons of the trinity, but each focuses on one person more than the others.

    “Evangelicals have women pastors”

    I would qualify that – SOME evangelicals have women pastors. I do not believe it is Bilbical.

    I think the so-called american dream is inclusive, as everyone gets the same opportunties. But I dont think its inclusive in that one must work and strive to get ahead.

    But while Jesus hung out with sinners, He still demanded people believe. The message is inclusive, as everyone has the same opportunity, but it is not inclusive, as each person must decide for themselves.

Leave a Reply, Please!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.